The Enigma Variations is a piece for orchestra by the English composer Edward Elgar. It has one theme and 14 variations, and each variation is a musical picture of someone Elgar knew. The ninth is called “Nimrod.” It is slow and noble, and it is played in Britain at times of remembrance. Elgar also hid a puzzle in the piece that no one has solved for sure. The whole work lasts about 30 minutes, and “Nimrod” lasts about four.
Quick facts
- Composer: Edward Elgar, who lived from 1857 to 1934
- Written: 1898 and 1899
- Length: about 30 minutes
- Played by: an orchestra
- Full title: Variations on an Original Theme
- Dedicated to: “my friends pictured within”
How it began
One evening in 1898, Elgar came home tired from a day of teaching the violin. He sat at the piano and played whatever came into his head.
His wife, Alice, said that she liked the tune and asked what it was. He said, “Nothing, but something might be made of it.”
Then he began to play the tune the way some of their friends might have played it. One friend was loud and gruff. One was shy. Alice laughed and guessed who each one was.
The game turned into the piece that made Elgar famous. He was 42.
The friends
Each variation has a set of initials or a nickname at the top. Here are some of them.
| Number | Name in the score | Who it was | What to listen for |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | C.A.E. | His wife, Alice | The theme, made warmer and fuller |
| 4 | W.M.B. | A country gentleman | He barks out the plans for the day and slams the door |
| 7 | Troyte | An architect who tried to learn the piano | Pounding drums and a lot of noise |
| 9 | Nimrod | His best friend, a music editor | A slow tune that grows from a whisper |
| 10 | Dorabella | A young friend | Light, fluttering woodwinds |
| 11 | G.R.S. | An organist and his bulldog | The dog falls into a river, paddles out, and barks |
| 12 | B.G.N. | A cellist | A solo cello opens and closes it |
| 13 | Three stars | A friend away on a sea voyage | A quiet drum roll for the ship’s engines |
| 14 | E.D.U. | Elgar himself | A bold march. “Edu” was Alice’s name for him |
Read classical music about cats and dogs for more about the bulldog.
Why “Nimrod”?
Elgar’s best friend was a man named August Jaeger, who worked for his publisher. “Jaeger” is the German word for “hunter.” In the Bible, Nimrod is a mighty hunter. The title is a friendly joke on the name.
The music is not a joke. Elgar had been low and ready to give up composing. Jaeger came to see him and talked about Beethoven, who kept writing through far worse troubles. Elgar said that the variation is the record of that talk. Its opening has an echo of a slow movement by Beethoven.
What to listen for in “Nimrod”
| When | What you hear |
|---|---|
| The start | The strings alone, as soft as they can play |
| The first minute | The tune rises a little, falls back, and rises again |
| The middle | Woodwinds and horns join, one layer at a time |
| The peak | The full orchestra, with brass and drums, at the top of a long climb |
| The end | The sound drops away within a few bars |
The whole piece is one slow build from almost nothing to the full orchestra. It never hurries.
“Nimrod” is played each November at the national service of remembrance in London. It is also played at funerals and memorials. Many people in Britain know the tune without knowing its name.
The puzzle
“Enigma” means “riddle.” The word sits over the theme in the score. He said that another, larger tune “goes” with the whole piece and is never played.
People have been guessing for more than a hundred years. Some think the hidden tune is a well-known song. Some think that it is not a tune at all, and that the hidden theme is friendship. Elgar never told. He said that the secret would stay a secret.
Things to do together
- Guess the person. Play a variation without the notes above. Ask your child what kind of person it is: loud, gentle, funny, or sad.
- Grow with the music. In “Nimrod,” start curled up on the floor. Rise a little at a time, and stand tall at the peak.
- Find the bulldog. In variation 11, listen for the splash, the paddling, and the bark.
- Paint a friend in sound. Pick someone you both know. Make up a short tune or a rhythm that fits them.
- Draw the volume. Draw one line for “Nimrod” that shows how loud the music is from start to end.
- Solve the riddle. Ask your child what the hidden theme might be. No one can mark the answer wrong.
Questions to ask
- Which friend would you most like to meet?
- How does Elgar make “Nimrod” grow?
- What would a variation about you sound like?
Words to know
- Theme: the main tune
- Variation: a new version of a tune
- Enigma: a riddle or a puzzle
- Crescendo: getting louder
Print and play
Read composers and their animals.
Draw a friend on a listening journal page. Read Elgar for kids, Pomp and Circumstance for kids, and dynamics in music. More guides are listed in classical music listening guides for kids.
More from this guide
This article is part of Classical music listening guides for kids: famous pieces, one at a time.
1812 Overture for kids: what to listen for
A parent's listening guide to Tchaikovsky's 1812 Overture: the story of the battle, the two tunes that fight, the cannons and bells, and games to play.
A Midsummer Night's Dream by Mendelssohn for kids
A listening guide to Mendelssohn's Midsummer Night's Dream music for kids: the overture he wrote at 17, the fairies, the donkey, and the Wedding March.
Adagio for Strings by Barber for kids: what to hear
Adagio for Strings by Samuel Barber for kids: what to hear in this slow, famous American piece, how it grew from a quartet, and when it is played.
Aida for kids: story and music
Aida for kids: Verdi's opera set in ancient Egypt in plain words, who is who, the Triumphal March and other tunes to hear, and a note on the ending.
Air on the G String by Bach for kids: what to hear
A parent's guide to Bach's Air on the G String: where the nickname came from, the walking bass and long notes to listen for, and calm things to do.
Album for the Young by Schumann: a guide for piano families
A parent's guide to Schumann's Album for the Young: the 43 piano pieces he wrote for his children, ten to hear first, and his rules for young musicians.
Use it with your kids
Print a listening page, a practice chart, or a composer fact sheet. Or try a tool, such as the composer timeline or the piece picker.